Centerville Pie Company

Centerville Pie Company in Cape Cod is a culinary gem celebrated for its flaky, buttery crusts and an array of unique savory and sweet pies. While standout dishes like the Thanksgiving turkey pie have garnered rave reviews for their moist, flavorful fillings and delectable crusts, some offerings, such as the buffalo chicken pie, evoke mixed opinions due to intriguing flavor profiles. Locals appreciate the homey vibe and the opportunity to sample new creations, making it a beloved spot for both casual diners and pie enthusiasts.

Overall, customers had mixed experiences with the pies. The crust consistently received high praise for its taste and texture, with reviewers enjoying the Thanksgiving turkey and shepherd's pies. However, there were significant complaints about the chicken pot pie, which was described as flavorless and poorly constructed. Although some products were well-received, dissatisfaction with selection and inconsistency in quality may deter potential customers.