Chatham Penny Candy Store

Chatham Penny Candy Store exudes a nostalgic charm that transports visitors to a bygone era. Renowned for its delectable fudge and delightful ice cream, the cozy store offers a warm atmosphere thanks to its friendly owner. Though prices may reflect the area's tourist appeal, locals treasure the unique experience of browsing classic candies and engaging in friendly banter. It’s a sweet slice of small-town Americana perfect for those seeking a taste of tradition.

The business has mixed reviews, with some customers enjoying the nice selection of fudge and ice cream, appreciating the friendly service, and describing it as a cute candy store. However, several others criticized the high prices, stating they found them excessive, with complaints about limited selection and a decline from its former charm. Overall, it appeals to some while deterring others due to cost and service issues.